What To Consider When Choosing A Plant-Based Milk For Your Kids

by | Mar 8, 2019

Interested in going dairy-free as a family? Great! Here are some things to consider when it comes to plant-based milks for little ones.

The milk and dairy shelves at the grocery store, full of dairy and nondairy alternatives

When people find out that I’m raising plant-based kids, many will ask where my boys get essential nutrients if they don’t drink cow’s milk.

There’s so much confusion around the idea of dairy alternatives for kids that it’s often the one obstacle preventing parents from making the full plant-based switch.

We’ve been conditioned to believe that dairy is sort of a gold standard for childhood nutrition. Kids need nutrients like calcium, protein, fat, and vitamin D for proper growth and development, and dairy provides these. It’s also calorically-dense, affordable, and easily accessible.

However, more parents are recognizing the health and ethical concerns associated with dairy and are looking for alternatives.

Enter, Plant Milks

Luckily, cow’s milk isn’t the only milk option, nor is it a requirement for raising healthy, thriving kids. To be clear, milk of any kind isn’t a necessity in life – but if your family chooses to drink it, there are now at least ten varieties of plant milks, and that number is growing.

Plant milks can be very nutritious. They’re also cruelty-free and more environmentally sustainable than dairy.

Plant milks are typically made by soaking and pulverizing either legumes (beans, nuts, seeds) or grains (oats, quinoa, rice) with water and draining out the solids. Commercial plant milks are sometimes flavored or sweetened, and are usually fortified with vitamins and minerals.

The Role of Plant Milks For Kids

Neither plant nor cow’s milk should be used as a replacement for breast milk or infant formula, especially before one year. After that, it’s generally considered safe to start introducing plant milks (as long as there are no allergy concerns). It’s best to choose a full-fat option for kids under the age of two.

That being said, by the time kids start weaning, they’re likely becoming familiar with a variety of solid foods. And while milk is a nice vehicle for additional nutrients, it’s these foods that should become their primary source of nutrition. Plant milks can be served alongside meals and can also be used in recipes, but shouldn’t be relied upon for meeting all of a child’s nutritional needs.

There are plenty of plant-based proteins that can be age appropriate, like canned beans, tofu, lentils, peas, and quinoa. Avocados and thinned nut butters are packed with healthy fats. Pureed or mashed fruits, veggies, and grains provide complex carbohydrates, fiber, vitamins, and minerals.

Milk Pitcher and Glass

Choosing A Plant Milk For Your Family

If you’re wondering which plant milk is best for your kids, my vague answer is that 1) it depends and 2) there isn’t necessarily just one. No plant milk is quite like another, and there are a few things to take into consideration when choosing the right one(s) for your family:

  • They can have very different nutritional profiles.

Plant milks are highly heterogeneous, depending on the type of milk and the brand who makes it. Soy and pea are high in protein, while almond, cashew, and coconut generally have none. Hemp, soy, pea, and coconut typically offer more fat than the nut milks. The types and amounts of vitamins and minerals can differ, too. Oat, coconut, soy, flax, and hemp are often fortified with vitamin B12, whereas almond, cashew, hazelnut, quinoa, and pea may not be. Similarly, certain varieties are better sources of vitamins E, A, and D, iron, and calcium than others.

  • Their ingredient lists can vary significantly.

Some brands take a minimalist approach to ingredients, while others use flavorings, sweeteners, and sometimes controversial thickeners like carrageenan. Some milks are naturally high in protein, while others (usually “protein” versions of nut or flax milk) have isolated pea protein added. Some milks also contain natural fats, while others have added oils to achieve this.

  • They can be unexpected sugar bombs.

Added sugars run rampant in our food system and plant milks are not immune to this, especially those that come in chocolate flavor. Look for rice sweetener, cane juice, or cane sugar in the ingredient list. Sweetened milks can contain anywhere from 5-13 grams of sugar per cup. Fortunately, there are unsweetened versions available of almost every kind (and they will be labeled as such). Oat and rice milk, however, often contain more sugar that you might expect, even when none is added.

  • They can contain unwanted substances.

Soymilk is very popular, but the majority of soy grown in the United States is genetically modified. For this reason, I recommend organic soymilk. Choosing organic plant milks in general will reduce your family’s exposure to pesticides. Rice milk is also at high risk for arsenic contamination, and there’s no label or certification that addresses this.

  • They may contain allergens.

Before you start introducing plant milks, it’s a good idea to make sure your child isn’t allergic to soy or nuts. I’ve seen many milks that are actually a combination of multiple plants, like almond and cashew with pea, or coconut with almonds. Kids with tree nut allergies should also avoid milks made from hazelnuts, macadamia nuts, and pecans.

My Two Cents On Plant Milks for Kids

With these few considerations in mind, plant milks can be a fantastic alternative to dairy for kids. Keep a few plant milks with different nutritional makeups on rotation in your household, with at least one being calorically-dense and high in protein, like soy milk.

Choose organic, unsweetened, non-rice versions as much as possible, and read labels. You can also make your own, which is very easy and requires few ingredients – just remember that it won’t be fortified like commercial milks are.

Speak with a registered dietitian who is knowledgeable in plant based nutrition for more individually-tailored advice about dairy alternatives for kids.

Whatever you decide, talk to your kids openly about why you don’t drink dairy and what milks you enjoy instead. Most of all, be confident in your decision to raise a compassionate, plant-based family!

Tell Me Below:

  • What non-dairy milk alternatives does your family drink?
  • What other questions do you have about cow’s milk alternative for kids?

2 Comments

  1. Cherie Hirsch

    Thank you for the info on plant milk.

    I’m a vegan nanny to an omnivorous baby and family. When she hit one year, they started giving her milk and she got a bit of eczema so they decided (without my input:) to take her off dairy milk and give her almond milk. She does not like it. Their pediatrician told them it’s fine as long as she’s getting enough healthy fats. They do give her dairy cheese and yogurt so she doesn’t really need anything but water IMO. Mom bought the best cow’s milk she could find last week and started giving her a bit again, I think because of the notion that kids “should” be drinking milk or there’s something wrong. They don’t want a vegan baby, just a healthy one. I’m only with her for snacks and lunch a few days a week. Any ideas?

    Reply
    • Lauren Panoff

      Hi Cherie! I think it’s wonderful that you want to help. Have they asked for your input? If not, feeding kids can be a sensitive subject and personally I would tread lightly here. You could certainly offer some suggestions if you think they are open to receiving them, or say that you’d love to help with ideas if they’re ever interested in brainstorming together. Do you prepare her lunch and snacks? Does she eat a variety of healthy fats? Would they be open to trying a different non-dairy milk besides almond? Soy milk is technically the most similar to cow’s milk, so if mom is mostly concerned about the nutritional makeup and wants to offer a milk, that might be a good option.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

MEET YOUR WRITER

Jacqui portrait

Lauren has been a registered dietitian since 2010, with extensive experience in public health and plant-based nutrition. Through writing and speaking, she specializes in normalizing and elevating the plant-based (vegan, vegetarian, and the like) lifestyle.

Learn More

View Categories

WORK WITH LAUREN

Lauren offers copywriting for plant- based brands in the form of articles, blog posts, social media, newsletters & email sequences, product descriptions, presentations, and sales pages.

View all Services

Calcium Rich Foods on a Plant-Based Diet

Calcium Rich Foods on a Plant-Based Diet

Considering a plant-based diet but concerned about finding enough calcium rich foods? Don’t be! There are plenty of dairy-free calcium sources that can help you meet calcium needs on a vegan diet.

Top 10 Health Reasons For Going Vegan

Top 10 Health Reasons For Going Vegan

Health reasons for going vegan. If you want to adopt a diet to improve your health, plant-based is where it’s at! Here are some of the top evidence-based health benefits of a vegan diet.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This